The Way of the Pierogi


Before the Lovely R departed back to Poland, I was lucky enough to experience a hands on pierogi lesson. Pierogi is a Polish style dough dumpling stuffed with various fillings. R’s English is pretty darned good, despite her insistence that it isn’t. It is miles better than my Polish. (Ummm, non-existent.) As our lesson progressed, I tried to ask if she ever eats the pierogi straight after being boiled or does she always let it sit, then pan-fry and eat it. As we did on our lovely Polish picnic day.

Using her English/Polish dictionary, I found the word ‘boil’ and pointed at the translation. Horrified, the Lovely R vehemently shook her head and exclaimed ‘No, no!’ We spent a good few minutes, toing and froing, trying to understand what the other was saying. I showed her the dictionary again, this time, my finger was no long blocking the second meaning of the word ‘boil.’ It turns out that the first meaning had been an actual ‘boil’ that appears on the skin, a somewhat unsavoury medical condition.

Much laughter ensued.

This is one picture heavy post. I really tried to capture the intricacies of this process and I hope I have done the Lovely R justice. You can make the dough first then prepare the filling whilst the dough rests. R will often make the filling the night before then make the dough the next day. The dough also freezes well. She works fast. It is harder than it looks to make the dough stick, you must use all of your finger strength. No namby pamby weak fingers please. (Which obviously mine are.) The lovely R’s advice. ‘Practice will make you a master and Be Strong.’

For that is The Way of the Pierogi.


Pierogi Dough
1 kilo plain flour
400ml boiling water and extra ready if needed
1/3 cup Olive oil
1 tsp Salt

Add oil to the flour then add the water gradually, you may not need all the water, or you may need a dash more. We used all 400ml and added another 3 tbl boiling water.
Bring the mixture together in the bowl then turn out onto a floured bench or board and knead until the gluten is activated, approximately 5 minutes.
Cover the dough in clingfilm and rest for half an hour minimum, up to one hour maximum at room temperature .
Flour a tray to place the pierogi on, and flour your workspace.
When the dough is soft and springy it is ready. Take a large ball of dough, around the size of a large orange.
Using a rolling pin, roll the dough, moving the dough regularly to avoid sticking, R worked it quite hard and it is quite elastic. Roll to approx 1mm thickness.
Using a glass or cutter about 8cm to cut out the pierogi shapes.
Use the scraps and add back into the dough.
Place a large teaspoon of filling onto each round of dough. (R works quickly.)
To shape the pierogi, pick up one pierogi and fold in into a crescent shape, press filling into the dough all the way and start to crimp around the edges.
As R says, Be Strong! Then turn over and crimp the other side. If there is too much filling, press it in with your index finger before crimping.
Don’t be afraid to pull the dough out as you crimp, you must have a good space between the filling and the dough so the two sides stick together without filling getting in the way. Again, Be Strong!
This filling used up about half of the dough made, we rolled out another batch once the first dough was used up. You can freeze leftover dough.

3 potatoes, cooked and mashed
1 tbl oil and 1 tbl butter
1 medium onion, finely diced
300g-350g farm style cottage cheese, similar to Polish cheese. (Approximately the same weight of potatoes as cheese, with a tad extra cheese. Cheese must be slightly sour.
1 tbl Veggie stock powder (this is not mandatory)
1 1/2 tsp dried marjoram
Salt to taste, (more if not using vegetable stock)
Pepper to taste

Cook onion in oil and butter until golden brown. Cool slightly.
Grate the cheese then add the cheese, stock powder (if using), marjoram, salt and pepper to the potato mixture.
Add half of the onion mixture to the cheese and potato mixture and mix well. R used her clean hands. The other half of the onion mixture is sprinkled on top of the cooked pierogi.
R usually makes the filling the day before or makes the filling whilst the dough is resting.

To cook pierogi
1 tsp salt
2 tbl oil
Fill a large saucepan over half way and bring to the boil.
Add about 8-10 pierogi at a time. When they float to the surface and have cooked for about 3-4 minutes, and feel tender, they are ready.
Meat pierogi take a bit longer, about 4-5 minutes.
You can eat them straight away topped with fried onion or refrigerate and pan fry on each side later in butter and oil, then top with the onion. (Which answered the infamous ‘boiling’ question, you can eat them straight away or wait and pan-fry them later. I have even re-poached them to keep them as softer type dumplings. It’s up to you!)

If you are not cooking the pierogi straight away, cover the tray with a tea towel until ready to boil. It is ok if they get a bit drier and with a bit of air, it means they are less likely to stick.

Different filling ideas include a sweet variation of fresh blueberries. Do not add any sugar as it will bring out the juices and the pierogi will collapse. Serve them with a a sugar and butter sauce and sweet whipped cream.

Another popular vegetarian filling is finely chopped sauerkraut, dried mushrooms and onion. Meat fillings include ground lamb, pork and beef variations. When making meat pierogi, make the crescent shape then bring it around to the corners and squeeze into a tortellini shape. (See the photos at the very end. )

We did experiment with a gluten free version which was pretty darned tasty, however, it requires a tad more refining, so stay tuned.

Cheergerm Feb 1510


30 thoughts on “The Way of the Pierogi

  1. A.PROMPTreply

    Wow. These look so scrummy, but also like a whole lot of prep time. Have to have quite a while before I can get these ones tried, but I’d be so proud to make my own!

    • They were little sweetchops indeed Mrs Italian! She was struggling with the cold when she got home so I am sure she would love a plane ticket! Ha! I did make quite a few with her but the real test will be when I am on my own….have to do it again soon so I don’t lose the little knack that I gained.

  2. Oh yum! I usually panfry them, but I love the idea of poaching them. They would make good dumplings in a clear soup, yes? LOL about the “boils.” So far as I know, pierogis don’t cause any health problems other than carb cravings and increased pudginess ๐Ÿ™‚

    • Yes LM! I think they would be great in a clear soup, yummy. I think you are right about pierogi health problems…particularly in winter! Burble….give me another pierogi…burble…

  3. The Way of the Pierogi. I love it. So zen. And I can clearly picture the face of horror with the dictionary misinterpretation.
    I’ve been thinking about you with your prized Polish visitors and how one of the most cherished things my folks ever gave me (and each of their four kids) was the recipe book that all our celebratory foods came from. I hunted it down on my American Amazon–as for some wonky reason, the authors limited their reach to other folks not living in this country by giving it the title they did–but I couldn’t find it on your Aussie equivalent. Maybe ebay?? Anyway, here’s the link:
    Mine is dogged-eared and flour covered. It is loved. It is a national treasure.

    • It was quite a zen like process isn’t it? Something to enjoy on a quiet day with some lots of time. That book sounds the bees knees, Iovely that you all have a copy.I have two Polish cookbooks but that one sounds pretty special. I am going to go and investigate further…off onto the communication highway I go! (I must have been a bloodhound in a past life, I adore tracking things down….)

  4. Sounds like a wonderful time in the kitchen in spite of, maybe because of the language difference. I love all dumpling things no matter their country of origin or what they are filled with. Look for ward to the GF version

    • Thanks Mrs R, it was one of those times that I just sat in the moment and enjoyed a true sharing of food love and food history and some great laughs. Yes, dumplings are awesome hey? I hope I can get the GF version right, they were pretty good just need a bit of rejigging.

  5. You crack me up – boil(1), boil(2)! Love perogies. These were always found in our freezer when I was growing up – ready to be pulled out, boiled and smothered in butter and onions. You are so lucky to have R show you how to make them! Great photo documentation. Just might try making some – potato and sauerkraut for me.

    • It took about five minutes to sort out the confusion and gosh how we laughed! Love your pierogi memory and you have made my day with your comments about the photos. I hope you get to them and they will certainly help me when I make them again, ha!

    • That is an awesome idea! I feel so tired today that the thought of ever cooking again seems completely out of reach. May just start cutting pictures out instead. Could be the next big thing? (Yeah, like Pinterest but oh, hang on…been done…sigh…)

  6. Amy

    My sister’s Polish descended husband is going to love this recipe! He has fond memories of inhaling piles of these after surfing sessions near her house in Victoria, and now that he lives in Queensland he can’t get piles of pierogi after a surf. Thanks Cheergerm! Now my sister can make them herself!

  7. Scrumptious looking things! Looking at your photo with the filling dolloped on, I thought no way, but strong fingers did the trick! I made Cornish pasties last night so I’ve had recent poking in filling and crimping edges experiences. Topped with fried onions sounds so naughty. My mouth is watering – as it does with every one of your recipes. ๐Ÿ™‚

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s